Home Projects Portfolio Dashboard Export PDF Log in

Embrace Simplicity: Deferring Abstraction in EventPass

When developing EventPass, there's a natural inclination to abstract common functionalities early on. However, premature abstraction can lead to complications down the line. It's often better to embrace simplicity and defer abstraction until a clear pattern emerges.

The Pitfalls of Early Abstraction

Creating abstractions too early can result in solutions that don't quite fit all use cases. Initially, different parts of the EventPass project might seem similar, tempting developers to unify them under a single abstraction. This can lead to overly complex and inflexible code.

A Practical Scenario

Consider a scenario where EventPass requires sending notifications to users through different channels, such as email and SMS. An initial approach might be to create a generic notification service to handle all channels. However, if the requirements for each channel vary significantly, this abstraction can quickly become cumbersome.

For example:

// Initial approach: Generic notification service
class NotificationService {
  public function send(User $user, string $message, string $channel) {
    if ($channel === 'email') {
      // Send email
    } elseif ($channel === 'sms') {
      // Send SMS
    } else {
      // Handle other channels
    }
  }
}

As new channels are added or the requirements for existing channels change, the NotificationService can become bloated with conditional logic. This not only makes the code harder to maintain but also increases the risk of introducing bugs.

A Better Approach: Defer Abstraction

Instead of creating a generic service upfront, it's often better to start with separate, independent implementations for each channel:

// Separate implementations for each channel
class EmailNotificationService {
  public function send(User $user, string $message) {
    // Send email
  }
}

class SMSNotificationService {
  public function send(User $user, string $message) {
    // Send SMS
  }
}

This approach allows each channel to evolve independently without affecting the others. When a clear pattern emerges across multiple channels, then it makes sense to introduce an abstraction. By waiting, you'll have a better understanding of what needs to be abstracted and what should remain separate.

Key Takeaway

Resist the urge to abstract too early. Start with simple, independent implementations and only introduce abstractions when a clear pattern emerges. This will result in more maintainable and flexible code for the EventPass project.


Generated with Gitvlg.com

Embrace Simplicity: Deferring Abstraction in EventPass
Daniela Homobono

Daniela Homobono

Author

Share: